The best orientation programs both welcome students and evolve with them. While completion rates can tell you who finished, they don’t tell you what resonated, what confused students, or where they disengaged. 

By looking deeper at how students interact with your orientation, you can uncover which parts are working, which need improvement, and how to make the experience more meaningful and memorable for every incoming student.

1. Orientation Completion and Drop-Off Rates

Completion rates are a great starting point, but they don’t tell the full story. Where students stop, whether halfway through an online module or before the final in-person session, often reveals friction points.

High drop-off rates may point to content fatigue, confusing navigation, or inaccessible design. For example, if data shows that 35% of students abandon the online platform during the “Campus Safety” section, it might indicate that the material is too long or not engaging enough.

KPIs to Track:

• Completion percentages
• Session or page abandonment rates
• Average time to completion

How to Use the Data: If completion rates drop after a specific module, consider breaking the content into shorter segments, adding interactivity (i.e. quizzes or reflection prompts), or clarifying instructions to help students move through more easily.

2. Questions Still Being Asked Post-Orientation

When the same questions keep showing up after orientation, that’s your sign that something isn’t clicking. If advisors or help desks repeatedly hear “How do I register for classes?” or “Where can I find my course schedule?”, it means the content isn’t sticking.

KPIs to Track:

• FAQs logged by advising teams
• Call or chat logs from support services
• Repeated help desk or event follow-up themes

How to Use the Data: Compare the top recurring questions with your orientation agenda or online orientation content. If certain topics are consistently misunderstood, rework how you present them. Try simplifying visuals, clarifying instructions, or adding a short recap video for reinforcement.

3. Student Confidence or Readiness Scores

Orientation is about providing the right information so that students feel ready. Collecting self-reported confidence or readiness scores gives insight into how well your program prepares students emotionally and practically for campus life.

KPIs to Track:

• Pre- and post-orientation surveys
• Pulse check forms
• Feedback scale responses (e.g., “I feel confident registering for classes” or “I know where to go for academic support”)

How to Use the Data: If confidence scores are low around academic advising, add a brief “Getting Ready for Advising” checklist. If students feel unprepared to navigate campus, consider a virtual tour or student-led panel. Tracking readiness over time also helps measure whether program changes are improving student outcomes year over year.

‍

4. Engagement with Key Content or Resources

Even the most polished orientation won’t have an impact if students don’t engage with the material. Tracking how students interact with resources (videos, handouts, links, etc.) reveals what captures their attention and what doesn’t.

‍KPIs to Track:

• Clicks, downloads, or QR code scans
• Video watch time and completion percentages
• Resource link tracking or page analytics

How to Use the Data: For example, if only 40% of students open your financial aid walkthrough, consider moving it earlier in the sequence or turning it into a short, student-narrated video. If student engagement spikes with student stories, replicate that tone and style in other sections to keep momentum high.

5. Quality of Feedback: Not Just a Star Rating

Five-star ratings are nice, but they don’t tell you the why. Written feedback often holds the richest insights into what students valued, where they struggled, and what they want more or less of.

‍KPIs to Track:

• Open-ended survey comments
• Qualitative feedback themes (e.g., “too long,” “love the speakers,” “tech issues”)
• Staff debrief notes and facilitator reflections

How to Use the Data: If students praise certain sessions or facilitators, highlight those moments as strengths to build on. If feedback shows frustration with technology or accessibility, prioritize those fixes before the next cohort. Over time, tracking qualitative patterns helps you identify what consistently works and what needs rethinking.

Building a Better Orientation Starts with Better Data

The most effective orientation programs look deeper, beyond attendance numbers, to how students engage, what they retain, and how confident they feel walking into day one. By tracking the right mix of quantitative KPIs and qualitative insights, institutions can evolve their orientation from a mandatory milestone into a meaningful moment of connection. 

Every dataset, survey, and conversation becomes a guidepost for building an experience that truly welcomes students into your community.